How so, Shawn's sollution is to make money with out ads. What would your solution be.
Step 1: Remove ads
Step 3: Profit!
Most of the reasons he gives for removing ads apply to other forms of making money too. Asking for donations? You might do okay the first round, but after that it will dwindle. Charge for subscriptions? Unless you have a niche within a niche within a niche that people can't get enough of, you'll have too much free competition for that. Sell merchandise? That's just a whole new level of overhead... and how many people really want a logo T-shirt that says "HorseForums.com.net.co.uk"?
I sometimes get “Why don’t you do what Wikipedia does and have fundraisers?” and the answer is, “When you actually develop your own content and don’t rely on 100,000 volunteers, and when you aren’t the #1 search item that comes up, and when you didn’t start with millions in capital, that’s not as practical as it sounds.”
But i still have no idea what you would do. Ads are getting less and less people getting used to ad blockers and how to install. You only need a few geeks that learn people to install ad blockers and you block many ads.
I was at a Google event a few weeks back, they showed us an anti adblock product that they said could come out this year where adblock users are allowed to visit a site X times and then have the option to pay a fee for X days/months of access or the site will be blocked.
That doesn't sound like a google product.
I think it was the updated version of google contributor.
One of the main reasons ad blockers exist is because of video ads that play automatically or when you roll over them, ads that play sound automatically or when you roll over them, or ad systems like Taboola that just generally piss everybody off. Ad networks need to stop dealing with these kinds of ads. I know they make a lot of money - but who cares when you're business is going to close as a result (of ad blockers).
Stop pissing off viewers with annoying ads and just let static ads do their thing.
I do reasonably well with having a Premium Member upgrade, payable annually, that removes banner ads from the site for all users in the user group. I only charge $10 for it, which is probably close to, or more, than the amount I'd earn through ad networks from the user.
Had to give this a 'disagree'. We have run relevant ads for 12 years (top and bottom for registered; top, side, bottom and after post x for guests). We also run a premium member subscription program with a good number of users. Both revenue streams are equally valuable. IMHE.
We used to run a "Please disable your popup blocker or become a premium member" notice, but have taken that down for 2 months now... and no change in ad revenue.